Don Pablo's Homemade Coffee Creamer (Simple Recipe)

Don Pablo's Homemade Coffee Creamer (Simple Recipe)

While many coffee lovers prefer pure black coffee, there are just as many who can’t live without their favorite creamer. Perhaps you’d like to know what ingredients you should have on hand in case you ever run out of creamer, or maybe you’re looking for a healthier option. If you’d like an easy recipe with simple ingredients, you’ve come to the right place. Here, we’ll show you how to make coffee creamer at home.

How to Make Coffee Creamer

To make a basic coffee creamer, you just need a few creamy ingredients and a mixing container. You can add other flavors like chocolate, cinnamon, and vanilla to this recipe. Stick around for some suggestions at the end!

  • 1 14-ounce can of sweetened condensed milk
  • 1¾ cups (14 ounces) of milk or cream
  • Extra flavoring, like spices and syrups (optional)
  • Mixing container: Mason jar, blender, or bowl and whisk
  • Storage container
  1. Add ingredients to mixing container. You can use a Mason jar, bowl, or blender for mixing.
  2. Mix well: Mix the ingredients thoroughly, until they form a liquid with an even consistency. If you’re using a bowl, you’ll probably want to mix with a whisk for the smoothest results.
  3. Store in the refrigerator: Your creamer is ready to serve immediately, and you should store leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator. Your creamer should last up to two weeks.

What variations can you make?

Spice cabinets

Here is where you can let your creativity flow. We’ll get you started with a few popular choices. For more creaminess, use heavy cream instead of milk. To cut back on the calories a bit, you can use low-fat sweetened condensed milk and any regular milk you prefer to fit your dietary needs.

In terms of flavors, take a look at your baking cabinet. Spices like nutmeg and cinnamon and extracts like vanilla, peppermint, almond, and hazelnut can make delicious creamers. You can even whip up a seasonal pumpkin spice mixture or add chocolate syrup for a decadent treat. We recommend adding about two teaspoons of spices and extracts to each batch of creamer.

When adding dry spices like cinnamon, heat a small amount of the base creamer with the spice so it will dissolve and not leave you with a grainy texture. Using pure vanilla extract instead of imitation vanilla will improve the creamer’s flavor.

Adjust the measurements to your taste, and let your spice cabinet be your playground!

*Alternative Options for Sweetened Condensed Milk*

Different milk variations on white wooden counter


Although sweetened condensed milk supplies the thick, decadent base for this homemade creamer, we realize that some coffee lovers may want less sugar, less fat, or a non-dairy option. You can use a milk alternative, like coconut, rice, soy, or almond milk, substitute non-fat milk, or use artificial sweeteners. If you’re not using sweetened condensed milk, you’ll want to cook your mixture on the stovetop to give it a nice, thick consistency. 

We hope you enjoy this homemade creamer as much as our family here at Don Pablo Coffee!

This recipe goes best with any of our delicious coffees!